About Us

Ye Olde Mustard Pot

Ye Olde Mustard Pot is a beautiful English Country Inn. Steeped with traditional features, such as oak beams & roaring fireplaces throughout. Outside there is a large beer garden & children’s play area. Surrounded by reservoirs, stunning woodland & glorious countryside, makes it the perfect place to visit & to stay.

We have three beautifully decorated double ensuite bedrooms, all of which have been designed with your comfort in mind. Dogs are very much welcome in our pub & to stay with you in our Bed & Breakfast.


Our pub dates back to 1760. The building was originally built by the Kay family & was a farmhouse. By 1780 the farmhouse had become the local watering hole, called The Barrel Inn. The Innkeeper was Ann Kay. In 1840, Joseph Kay took over the running of the pub. In 1841, Joseph renamed the pub to The Ship. In 2001, our pub had a major refurbishment & re-opened it’s doors with the name of Ye Olde Mustard Pot.

Today, Ye Olde Mustard Pot is run by Shaun White who has more than 20 years’ experience in hospitality industry.

Local Activities

  • We are a just a stones throw away from Underbank Reservoir, which has an activity centre.
  • Why not take a look around Penistone Open Market.
  • Penistone Paramount Cinema, the perfect place to go to step back in time.

We hope to see you soon…